Opinion from a Libertarian ViewPoint

How The Shutdown Can Be Used – LewRockwell

Posted by M. C. on January 12, 2019


We would never entrust a government functionary to secure the transport of valuable personal treasures like a Picasso or the Hope Diamond or a Faberge egg. There is a distinguished marketplace of professionals that handle that field far more adeptly. Then why do we trust a government functionary with securing our most vital form of long distance travel?

As all too many of us intimately recall, not only are planes able to be hijacked to the detriment of all on board, they can be used as guided missiles to the detriment of those on the ground, as was the case in the 9/11 attacks.

For some reason, rather than recognizing the failure of the quasi-governmental system and pushing government further out of the airline security process after the post 9/11 failures, we turned to the ever ineffective government to further step in to air travel security…

TSA Isn’t Doing Their Job, Isn’t Getting Paid, Now Is A Perfect Opportunity To Dissolve The TSA

With the TSA not doing their job, and not getting paid for that work, it’s a great time to withdraw this government welfare to airlines, by de-socializing airport security, leaving the responsibility to airlines to protect their passengers and equipment from curb to curb. According to one observer:

“If you’re not seeing long wait times at airports, there’s something on the security side they’re not doing.”

TSA officials publicly disagree with that. The fact remains, if it hasn’t already, at some point the current shutdown will affect the quality of work done by the already low quality TSA.

With luck Perhaps this shutdown might even have the impact of culling some federal employees. There are more than 57,000 working for the TSA. They aren’t getting their paychecks. They are calling in sick en masse.  How long would you do thankless work without a paycheck ? How long would you work with an IOU from the US government and its Trump-Pelosi gridlock? Perhaps some of them will just walk off the job and make the transition easier.

Our air travel must be secure. Not only has TSA done a universally terrible job of securing air travel, even by TSA’s own audits, but the single choke point created by relying on government and the strain of the government shutdown further highlights the risk of trusting a government functionary with the important duty of air travel security.

According to one report about the TSA replacing actual security measures with their own brand of “security theater”:

-mock explosives and guns slipped past screeners 95 percent of the time;

-TSA executives and whistleblowers described a toxic culture of retaliation and recrimination among the agency’s highest ranks;

-the agency failed to identify 73 aviation workers with potential links to terrorism;

-87 percent of Americans were unhappy with the TSA, and barely 10 percent had confidence it was effective at its job.

The Free Market Has Been Amazing In Many Other Areas And Will Be Perfect For Handling Air Security

The free market has virtually eliminated poverty in America. The only poverty exists according to a shifting contemporary definition of poverty that to a previous generation would look an awful lot like tremendous wealth and ease. These vast improvements in quality of life for all segments of the American public was accomplished by government simply letting commerce take place…

Why should we pretend that the free market can’t produce a solution for safer travel? Merely by the existence of competition, the free market always provides improved solutions. Why should we think for a moment that government functionaries are good at doing much of anything? Merely by the removal of competition and the related incentives, government always provides inferior solutions. I challenge anyone to find an example to the contrary.

The government shutdown gives us a great opportunity to shutter the TSA, and for the federal government to butt out, leaving air travel security, like all of the other most important functions, in the hands of the marketplace where it belongs.

Be seeing you


One Response to “How The Shutdown Can Be Used – LewRockwell”

  1. Kenneth T. said

    It is now and always was just a false sense of security.
    There is no difference now EXCEPT more groping (as in the case of my wife recently – AND she wasn’t even the one flying) and more restrictions on what we can carry on board.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: